How young people interpret challenge shapes what they do next. A young athlete makes a mistake. They try again and get the same result. The task is harder than they expected. Other people are watching and their frustration is beginning to show.
What happens next?
Do they lean in, experiment and try to work it out? Or do they protect themselves by retreating, blaming someone else or avoiding the task altogether?
We often explain the difference by pointing to something inside the young person. We believe that one is resilient and the other isn’t. One loves a challenge and the other gives up too easily.
But this overlooks an important question:
What does the challenge mean to them?
If difficulty feels like evidence that they are not good enough, withdrawing makes sense. But if difficulty is information that can help them improve, staying with it becomes possible. The challenge hasn’t changed. Its meaning has.
Two Ways to Experience Success
Achievement goal theory helps us understand this difference.
The theory suggests that people tend to define success in two broad ways: through an ego orientation or a task orientation.
An ego-oriented athlete evaluates their competence by comparing themselves with others:
- Am I better than them?
- Do I look capable?
- Did I win?
- What will people think if I fail?
Success means demonstrating ability. Therefore, struggle carries a risk. If I need to work hard, make mistakes or ask for help, other people might discover that I am not as capable as I hoped.
A task-oriented athlete uses a different reference point:
- Am I improving?
- What am I discovering?
- Can I solve this problem?
- What can this attempt teach me?
Success means developing competence rather than proving it.
This doesn’t mean task-oriented athletes don’t care about winning. Nor does it mean competition is harmful. Young people can want to beat an opponent and improve themselves at the same time.
The important difference is what they use as their primary evidence of success.
What Young People Believe Creates Success
Researchers Joan Duda and John Nicholls explored this with 207 high-school students.
They examined how the students understood achievement in both sport and school.
Students with a stronger ego orientation were more likely to believe success depended on possessing superior ability. Those with a stronger task orientation were more likely to connect success with effort, interest, learning and collaboration.
Task orientation was also the strongest predictor of satisfaction in schoolwork.
These young people weren’t simply choosing different goals. They were operating with different theories about how success happens.
One theory says: Success proves that I have ability.
The other says: Success comes from developing my ability.
This matters when things become difficult.
When success is about proving ability, struggle can feel threatening. When success is about developing ability, struggle has a purpose.
When Challenge Becomes a Threat
A more recent experiment shows how powerful this difference can be.
Researcher Candace Hogue worked with 72 high-school athletes, with an average age of approximately 16.
The athletes were placed into one of two groups.
The first group learned about the history of sport psychology.
The second completed a psychological-skills session designed to strengthen task orientation and create a caring, task-involving environment.
Then both groups faced a performance challenge.
They had to learn to juggle in an environment deliberately designed to create stress and make them feel evaluated.
The researchers measured the athletes’ psychological responses and took saliva samples to track changes in stress hormones.
The athletes who had completed the task-oriented session responded differently.
Compared with the control group, they reported less shame, humiliation, anxiety and negative emotion. They felt more control over their chances of success and maintained greater social and performance self-esteem.
Their bodies responded differently too.
The control group experienced a spike in the stress hormones cortisol and DHEA. The athletes prepared through the task-oriented session did not show the same increase.
A short intervention did not make the juggling task easier.
It helped change what the task meant.
The athletes were still uncertain. They could still make mistakes. Other people could still judge their performance.
But challenge was no longer only a test of whether they possessed enough ability.
It became something they could engage with.
A Challenge Mindset
This is what I call a challenge mindset.
A challenge mindset is not blind positivity. It is not pretending that difficult experiences are easy or telling young people to “embrace failure.”
It is a way of understanding what challenge is for.
Someone operating with a challenge mindset sees difficulty as a place where learning happens. Mistakes provide information. Effort is part of building competence. Not knowing is the starting point for discovery.
Challenge becomes something to work with rather than something to fear.
This distinction matters because simply exposing young people to difficult experiences is not enough.
A hard task can encourage curiosity, experimentation and persistence.
It can also create embarrassment, anxiety and withdrawal.
The outcome depends partly on the environment surrounding the challenge.
If mistakes lower a young person’s status, comparison is constant and only the best performers receive recognition, challenge becomes a public test of worth.
In that environment, avoiding difficult tasks can be a sensible act of self-protection.
But when improvement is visible, mistakes are treated as useful information and experimentation is encouraged, challenge carries a different message:
You are not here to prove what you can already do. You are here to discover what you might become capable of doing.
Designing for a Challenge Mindset
We often tell young people to be brave, persist and take more risks.
But their mindset is not created by our slogans. It is shaped by what the environment repeatedly rewards.
Here are three experiments for coaches, teachers and parents.
1. Change the measure
Before an activity, make the evidence of success clear.
Instead of only asking who won or completed the task best, identify something the learner can develop:
- A decision they are trying to improve
- A strategy they are testing
- A problem they are learning to solve
- A behaviour they can repeat more consistently
Winning can still matter. It just doesn’t have to be the only evidence that learning occurred.
2. Change the response to mistakes
When a young person makes a mistake, resist immediately correcting it. Instead ask:
- What did you notice
- What do you think happened?
- What might you try next
These questions reposition the mistake. It is no longer a verdict delivered by the coach. It becomes information the learner can use.
3. Change what receives attention
Look carefully at who receives your attention and why.
Do you mostly recognise the young people who produce the best outcomes?
Or do you also notice experimentation, persistence, intelligent adjustments and courageous attempts?
What receives attention becomes important. What becomes important shapes how young people approach the next challenge.
Challenge Is Interpreted
Some young people appear to naturally seek difficult experiences. Others avoid them.
But we should be careful about treating this as a fixed quality of the person.
A young athlete may explore confidently in one environment and become cautious in another. They may persist when working privately but withdraw when mistakes are publicly judged. They may enjoy difficulty until their place in the team depends on getting everything right.
Challenge is never experienced in isolation.
It is interpreted through the expectations, language, relationships and measures of success surrounding it.
That gives those of us who lead young people an important responsibility.
Our job is not simply to provide more challenge.
It is to design environments in which challenge can become useful.
Because young people are more likely to step towards difficulty when it offers them an opportunity to learn, not simply another chance to prove their worth.
—
Research
Duda, J. L., & Nicholls, J. G. (1992). Dimensions of achievement motivation in schoolwork and sport. Journal of Educational Psychology, 84(3), 290–299.
Hogue, C. M. (2020). Achievement goal theory-based psychological skills training session buffers youth athletes’ psychophysiological responses to performance stress. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 51, 101792.